
The Delhi State Consumer Commission dismissed HDFC ERGO General Insurance's appeal against a consumer court order that had directed the insurer to compensate a policyholder whose dengue treatment claim was denied. According to reports from The Economic Times, the commission ruled that a health insurance company cannot invoke a waiting-period condition to turn down a hospitalisation claim for a medical condition that is not covered by the policy's specified exclusions. The State Commission upheld the District Consumer Commission's order on October 6, finding that the waiting-period provision could not be applied to dengue fever diagnosis. The ruling is significant because the insurer's decision was tested against the actual diagnosis and the specific exclusions contained in the policy, rather than being accepted merely on the basis of the insurer's interpretation of the waiting-period clause.
The dispute originated in November 2019, when policyholder Mr Kumar tested positive for dengue fever on November 2 and was admitted to Max Super Speciality Hospital in Patparganj, Delhi, on November 3. As reported by The Economic Times, HDFC ERGO turned down his cashless treatment request on November 6, and Kumar was forced to pay ₹3.71 lakh at the first hospital and ₹8.11 lakh at the second facility. He subsequently shifted to Max Super Speciality Hospital in Vaishali, where his cashless request was again denied on November 12. Kumar remained hospitalised until November 21 and was compelled to borrow money and sell his wife's jewellery to arrange treatment funds. Kumar claimed a total of ₹17.99 lakh, including hospitalisation and pre- and post-hospitalisation expenses, which HDFC ERGO rejected citing a 24-month waiting period for PIVD treatment, a spinal disc condition.
In its October 31, 2023 order, the District Consumer Commission observed that HDFC ERGO had not established that the policyholder had received the relevant policy terms and conditions. According to The Economic Times, Vivek Kumar, Advocate, Delhi High Court, explained that the District Commission's decision was based on the insurer's failure to demonstrate that the policy documents containing exclusion conditions had been duly handed over to the policyholder. The commission directed payment of ₹10 lakh (the sum insured applicable to the relevant policy period) along with interest at 6% per annum, ₹30,000 as compensation and ₹20,000 towards litigation costs. The ruling emphasized that exclusionary conditions could not be enforced against the policyholder when the insurer failed to establish proper communication of policy terms.
During the appeal proceedings, the State Commission scrutinised Clause A(ii) of Section V, which specified a 24-month waiting period for particular illnesses, diagnoses and surgical procedures. As reported by The Economic Times, examining Kumar's medical records, the commission established that he had been hospitalised for dengue fever and noted that dengue did not feature among the medical conditions specified in the list attracting the 24-month waiting period. The commission found that HDFC ERGO had not provided any cogent justification for withdrawing the cashless facility and consequently dismissed the insurer's appeal while affirming the District Consumer Commission's order. The ruling reinforced that the 24-month waiting period did not apply to the respondent's illness when dengue was not covered by the enumerated exclusion.
The latest ruling in Madhu Sawhney vs Niva Bupa Health Insurance Co Ltd highlights the critical importance of accurate medical records in insurance claims. As reported by Business Standard, when 76-year-old Sawhney entered Max Super Speciality Hospital on December 23, 2023, an emergency assessment incorrectly recorded that she was suffering from chronic kidney disease, which her treating doctor later clarified she had no history of. The insurer sought additional records, including a doctor's affidavit, before rejecting her claim between January and April 2024. The District Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission-VIII (Central), Delhi, ruled in Sawhney's favour, finding that the insurer had not adequately explained why the provided documents were insufficient. Industry experts emphasize that while insurers can verify claims, they must make reasonable, evidence-based document requests and cannot indefinitely delay decisions over paperwork that has already been supplied.