
In September 2026, the Insurance Regulatory and Development Authority of India (IRDAI) dropped a consultation paper titled "Recalibrating Economics of Insurance Distribution."
To fix this, IRDAI proposed bringing back product-level commission caps that were removed in 2023, alongside a phased reduction in the expense of management (EoM) limit. For life insurers, the EoM would fall to 15% within two years and 12.5% within five years. For general insurers, it would drop from 30% to 20% over five years.
The market reacted immediately.
The consultation paper is not yet law—comments were invited until October 31, 2026, and IRDAI has not announced a date for draft regulations. But the direction is clear: tighter cost control, clearer accountability, and structured commission limits are coming.
The proposed caps vary by product and channel. For instance, first-year commissions on individual health insurance would be capped at 15% for distribution entities and 20% for agents. Renewals would be capped at 5% and 10% respectively. This structure hits the POSP (Point of Sales Person) model hardest.
A POSP is paid out of the distributor's own commission, so any cap on entities is passed down. Entity caps are generally lower than agent caps in the draft. Turtlemint Fintech Solutions estimates that under the proposal, a PoSP would earn about ₹1,000 less per month than an agent at similar volumes.
The earnings pressure is most acute in non-life insurance. PB Fintech management indicated that the net present value (NPV) of parts of this business could fall to roughly 33% to 40% of current levels if the proposals are implemented broadly in their existing form. Current take rates are 24% for health and 31% for motor third-party, with the higher motor figure reflecting the POSP business. Transcript
For insurers, commission is an acquisition expense. Cutting it could hurt sales growth, but it could also lower acquisition costs. The impact varies widely based on existing cost structures.
SBI Life Insurance and Canara HSBC Life Insurance are widely seen as better positioned.
It pays uniform commission to all distributors, so margins are consistent across channels. Management says it is "best placed" under the proposed norms and will adjust products and its operating-expense or commission structure to match the final guidelines. Transcript +1
Canara HSBC carries an expense ratio of about 18%, compared with the proposed 15% EoM threshold. Its bancassurance partner is also its promoter, so the partner's incentive to drive sales may be preserved even if the commission structure changes. Management says its commission rates are already moderate. Transcript
In contrast, insurers with higher expense ratios face a tougher adjustment. HDFC Life's current expense ratio is about 21%, while ICICI Prudential Life has already cut its cost-to-premium ratio to 18.3% in the first half of FY27. Brokerage commentary has generally viewed SBI Life and LIC as relatively better positioned than insurers with greater dependence on bancassurance and external distributors, such as HDFC Life and Max Financial.
The proposed rules reshape competitive intensity between bancassurance partners and digital-first distributors. For banks, insurance commission is largely fee income. Lower commissions mean lower fee income, but the bank does not take credit risk to earn it. For digital aggregators like Policybazaar, commission is core revenue.
The draft also proposes restrictions on volume-linked or reward-linked incentives for bank and NBFC employees selling insurance, and safeguards against compulsory bundling of insurance with loans. This could weaken the push from bank staff, even for captive insurers.
However, bancassurance has structural advantages. Captive banks sell mainly for their own insurer, so fee loss is partly recaptured through their ownership stake. Digital aggregators depend on many insurers paying commissions. The draft also proposes market infrastructure institutions (MIIs) such as Bima Sugam as "pull-based" digital channels, which could become a regulator-backed rival to aggregators.
Distributors are already planning their response. Turtlemint says it has historically not been the highest payer and relies on timely payment and platform reliability to retain POSPs. It expects the income gap for POSPs to be offset by selling health, life, and other financial products. Mutual funds and loans are already offered, and about 40% of premium comes from POSPs who cross-sell. Transcript +2
PB Fintech management outlined three responses: expanding non-insurance revenue as the regulator permits, accelerating ecosystem offerings, and evaluating other options. It is slowing hiring and reducing marketing spending, with variable costs expected to align with the new NPVs. Transcript +1
Both companies face limits. Turtlemint says cross-selling will take a few quarters to build, and if customers shift to direct channels, the impact on profitability would be immediate. PB Fintech says renewal profitability from insurance distribution is "extremely limited" under the current framing. Transcript +1
Insurers face a fundamental trade-off under the new framework: maintaining distribution breadth versus protecting margins. Lower commissions may slow sales if distributors push other products. Insurers may concentrate on lower-cost or captive channels and drop marginal ones.
The draft offers extra rewards above normal limits for business from rural areas, towns with populations up to 50,000, and smaller cities with populations up to 10 lakh. This could help protect breadth in underserved markets. Caps also vary by product and premium term, so insurers will shift towards products that remain profitable under the caps. SBI Life, for instance, is already reducing ULIP share from 66% to about 63%. Transcript
The timing of IRDAI's revised draft adds another layer of complexity. IRDAI has not announced a date for draft regulations, though reports point to 1 January or 1 April 2027 as possible implementation dates. The consultation closed on October 31 after an extension, with more than 650 responses.
Until the draft is released, companies are operating under uncertainty. Distributors are slowing hiring and spending. Insurers may delay products whose economics depend on commission levels. Companies are giving qualitative, not numerical, FY28 outlooks. Transcript
If the final rules soften the caps, near-term pressure on distributors eases and the relative advantage of SBI Life and Canara HSBC narrows. If the caps remain strict, the gap widens. For now, the insurance sector is in a holding pattern, waiting for the regulator's next move.