
The Indian government is expressing strong confidence in resolving the Scotch whisky import dispute within the coming days. Commerce Secretary Rajesh Agrawal stated on Friday that the Department of Revenue is working to resolve the issue, with classification being among the key concerns being discussed. As reported by ANI, Agrawal expressed optimism that 'It should be resolved very soon...We are very hopeful that it would be resolved in some days'. His remarks came after officials from the commerce and finance ministries met to discuss concerns raised by liquor companies over the classification of imported Scotch whisky. Representatives of the International Spirits and Wine Association of India (ISWAI) and the Confederation of Indian Alcoholic Beverage Companies (CIABC) also met Agrawal to flag the differences over customs duties, highlighting the industry's urgency for a swift resolution.
Indian customs authorities have launched a significant investigation into Scotch whisky imports, potentially undermining the trade benefits that have created competitive pressure on Indian whisky manufacturers. According to The Times of India, customs investigators are holding dozens of containers belonging to Pernod Ricard and Diageo, with both companies having more than 40 containers each stuck at ports. The dispute centers on whether bulk Scotch concentrates used to manufacture Indian whisky qualify for the reduced 75% duty under India's trade agreement with Britain. A confidential finance ministry memo dated November 4 instructs customs commissioners to continue applying the higher 150% tariff, arguing that bulk Scotch concentrates are not eligible for the pact's reduced duty. The memo states that importers are 'incorrectly' claiming benefits on bulk Scotch, which should attract the higher duty under customs classification for 'compound alcoholic preparations' effective since May 1. Following lobbying by the industry, the commerce ministry assured senior executives on November 2 that India would honour the trade pact and seek an early resolution, but the finance ministry's Directorate of Revenue Intelligence (DRI) memo has taken precedence, directing customs officials to ensure correct application of the higher duty.
Cheaper Scotch whisky is creating significant pressure on Indian whisky manufacturers, with imported labels now costing substantially less than locally produced spirits. According to The Times of India, Huli's rice malt whisky was launched in Karnataka at ₹2,650 for 750ml, while J&B Rare was priced at ₹1,375 at Bengaluru retailer Tonique in October. At these prices, J&B Rare costs ₹1,275 less, or about half as much as the locally made bottle. Tonique attributed the price reduction to local bottling, with the price falling from ₹2,835. An industry executive speaking on condition of anonymity to The Times of India noted that Indian buyers were also negotiating better purchase prices from Scotland, further intensifying the competitive pressure. Recent developments show Johnnie Walker Red Label prices declined from ₹2,810 to ₹2,620, while Black Label fell from ₹4,005 to ₹3,645 since September, as reported by The Times of India.
Small distillers that make their own spirits are facing particular challenges from the price differential. As reported by The Times of India, Huli Spirits founder Aruna Urs stated that 'The smaller players will not be able to survive'. Her Mysuru distillery makes spirits from locally sourced paddy and jaggery and does not import Scotch. Arun Kumar Parasa of Unistil Alcoblends said falling Scotch prices had adversely affected the Indian single malt industry, with lower duties on bulk Scotch imported by small and medium distilleries benefiting them 'very marginally'. Distribution difficulties and advertising restrictions remain longstanding hurdles for small manufacturers, according to the industry executive. The changing price structure is also bringing Scotch closer to Indian premium whisky brands, with Woodburns priced at ₹2,500 and Paul John Nirvana Indian single malt available at ₹2,360 at Tonique, as reported by The Times of India.
The customs dispute threatens to undermine the significant trade benefits that were expected from India's agreement with Britain. According to The Times of India, Scotch exports to India totalled $335 million in 2024, and the Scotch Whisky Association has forecast the trade deal could boost that figure by $1.34 billion over five years. About 80% of Scotch whisky imports from Britain by volume arrive in bulk and are used to produce Indian-Made Foreign Liquor, a category that blends small quantities of Scotch with other spirits and ingredients. The International Spirits and Wines Association of India has privately warned New Delhi that the dispute 'risks undermining, in practice, an important market-access benefit negotiated and agreed between India and the United Kingdom'. Companies affected include Pernod Ricard India, Diageo, Radico Khaitan and Allied Blenders and Distillers, with Pernod Ricard and Diageo each having more than 40 containers held at ports, while Bacardi has another five containers on hold, as reported by Reuters.
The finance ministry and commerce ministry are reportedly in discussions for an appropriate resolution of the tariff dispute, with the commerce ministry assuring senior executives on November 2 that it would honour the pact and resolve the dispute as soon as possible. However, tax officials have searched the offices of several companies, including Pernod and Diageo, and questioned executives in recent weeks, according to The Times of India. The prolonged delays could disrupt supplies, with more than 80 containers of Pernod, Diageo and Bacardi held at Indian ports, as reported by The Times of India. A senior finance ministry source told Reuters that the finance and commerce ministries were discussing an appropriate resolution of the matter. The changing price structure is encouraging some consumers to upgrade their purchases, with some customers who traditionally purchased Black & White moving towards Johnnie Walker Red Label and Black Label, as reported by The Times of India. John Distilleries acknowledged that greater affordability of established Scotch brands was increasing competitive pressure but said it remained focused on Indian provenance, craftsmanship and flavour. The dispute highlights the ongoing challenges of implementing trade agreements while maintaining domestic manufacturing competitiveness.