
The Allahabad High Court has quashed GST proceedings grounded in the omitted Rule 96(10) of CGST Rules, 2017. A division bench comprising Justice Saumitra Dayal Singh and Justice Swarupama Chaturvedi allowed seven connected writ petitions on September 30, 2026, ruling that proceedings initiated under the omitted rule but remained pending as of the date of omission had lost their legal foundation. The court found the matter entirely covered by the Supreme Court's decision in Goodluck India Ltd. Vs Union of India (2026 GSTL 3 [SC]), which held that continuation of pending proceedings required an appropriate legal provision preserving them.
The government has omitted CGST Rule 96(10) through notification 20/2024 Central Tax dated October 8, 2024, with retrospective effect from October 23, 2017. According to reports from Business Standard, this rule had restricted refunds of Integrated Goods and Services Tax (IGST) paid on exports where specified exemptions or concessions had been availed on imports or domestic procurements. The provision underwent several amendments and generated extensive litigation, with many exporters repaying amounts under departmental pressure before its final omission. The notification did not contain any saving clause preserving proceedings that had been initiated under the omitted rule but had not yet reached finality.
In Goodluck India Ltd. Vs Union of India (2026 GSTL 3 [SC]), the Supreme Court considered whether pending proceedings could survive the rule's omission. As reported by Business Standard, relying on the Constitution Bench judgment in Kolhapur Canesugar Works (2000 ELT 257 [SC]), the Court held that continuation of pending proceedings required an appropriate legal provision preserving them. The Court noted that the GST council's recommendation for prospective omission could not substitute for a saving clause in the notification, and saw the omission without a saving clause as intended to end unnecessary complications. The Allahabad High Court extracted the framing of the issue in Goodluck India Ltd. as follows: 'The question is whether, once Rule 96(10) was omitted without a statutory saving provision, the GST department could lawfully continue adjudication proceedings that had been initiated under that rule but remained pending and undecided as of the date of omission.'
The CBIC circular advises field formations to deal with pending proceedings concerning Rule 96(10) in accordance with the Supreme Court judgment. According to reports from Business Standard, the circular states that similar treatment applies, mutatis mutandis, to the omission of Rules 89(4A) and 89(4B) as well. The circular alone should not be assumed to remove statutory refund deadlines and finality of earlier orders, which may present legal obstacles to refund claims. The Allahabad High Court's ruling now provides clear precedent that proceedings initiated under omitted rules lose their legal foundation without appropriate saving provisions.
Exporters who surrendered refunds along with interest are questioning whether they can ask the government to return the money. As reported by Business Standard, if the Board's interpretation makes the omission effective from the rule's inception, why should the government retain amounts recovered solely under that rule? The government should initiate repayment of amounts recovered towards reversal of GST refunds, together with interest collected, wherever the omitted rules were the sole basis of recovery. The Allahabad High Court's ruling now provides additional support for exporters' claims that such proceedings had lost their legal foundation when the rule ceased to operate.
Returning these collections would release exporters' working capital and give practical effect to the Board's declared position. According to reports from Business Standard, closing pending demands while retaining earlier collections would leave the relief incomplete. The department already has records of these recoveries and should identify affected exporters, verify amounts collected, and arrange repayment without waiting for each exporter to initiate proceedings. Any legal obstacles should be addressed through an appropriate legal mechanism and a simple verification procedure, with the Allahabad High Court's ruling providing additional legal precedent for such relief.