
The Supreme Court on Wednesday established that income tax reassessment proceedings are fundamentally void if the tax department fails to issue a mandatory notice under Section 143(2) of the Income Tax Act, even if taxpayers participate in the proceedings. According to reports from Business Standard, a Bench of Justices Sanjay Kumar and Sanjeev Sachdeva delivered a landmark consolidated judgment affecting multiple appeals, holding that a taxpayer's participation in reassessment inquiries does not cure the jurisdictional arising from the total absence of such a notice. The court emphasized that the issuance of a notice under Section 143(2) is not merely a procedural formality but a foundational prerequisite for the Assessing Officer to frame an order under Section 143(3) as part of a reassessment process. In the latest ruling, the court reiterated that mere participation of the assessee in reassessment proceedings, in the absence of a notice under Section 143(2) of the Act, does not confer jurisdiction on the Assessing Officer to frame an assessment under Section 143(3) of the Act. The decision effectively bars the tax department from bypassing the statutory requirement to notify an assessee before initiating reassessment proceedings.
The tax department had argued that Section 292BB of the Act protected the reassessment proceedings because the taxpayers had participated in them. As reported by Business Standard, the provision deals with the deemed service of notices when a taxpayer appears in proceedings or cooperates with an inquiry. However, the court rejected this argument, stating that Section 292BB applies when a notice has been issued but the taxpayer disputes whether it was served, whether it was served on time or whether it was properly served. The court clarified that 'Where the Revenue itself contends that no notice was sent, as required under the Act, the provision of Section 292BB will have no applicability'. In the latest case, the dispute reached the apex court after the Revenue attempted to defend reassessments conducted against taxpayers for several assessment years, where the department had admittedly failed to issue the essential Section 143(2) notice despite subsequent correspondence under Section 142(1).
The Supreme Court laid down three key clarifications regarding income tax reassessment proceedings. According to the court's judgment authored by Justice Sachdeva, as reported by Business Standard, taxpayers can challenge reassessment proceedings on the ground that a notice under Section 143(2) was never issued, even if they participated in the proceedings without raising the objection at the time. The court also clarified that the department must issue the notice even when a taxpayer requests that the original income tax return filed under Section 139 be treated as the return filed in response to a reassessment notice under Section 148. Additionally, a letter issued by the assessing officer under Section 142(1), asking a taxpayer to explain why reassessment is proposed, does not satisfy the requirement of issuing a notice under Section 143(2). In the latest ruling, the court answered specific questions by holding that Section 292BB does not prevent an assessee from challenging the non-issuance of notice under Section 143(2) merely because the assessee participated in reassessment proceedings, and a letter issued under Section 142(1) during reassessment proceedings does not satisfy the mandatory requirement of notice under Section 143(2). The court also dismissed the department's attempt to use correspondence under Section 142(1) as a substitute for the mandatory Section 143(2) notice, stating 'A letter given by the Assessing Officer under Section 142(1) does not perform the functions intended by the notice under Section 143(2)'. The court reiterated that omission to issue the notice is not a curable procedural irregularity, and the notice provides the assessee an opportunity to produce evidence supporting the return.
Section 143(2) of the Income Tax Act, 1961, provides for a scrutiny notice issued by the Income Tax Department to verify that a taxpayer has not understated their income, claimed excessive losses or underpaid tax. As reported by Business Standard, without such a notice, the department cannot proceed with reassessment under Section 147 of the Act. The court's ruling establishes that taxpayer participation in reassessment proceedings does not make up for the department's failure to issue the mandatory notice, fundamentally altering the legal framework for income tax reassessment proceedings in India. The latest judgment reinforces that compliance with the mandatory statutory procedure is essential to the validity of reassessment proceedings, distinguishing between defects in notice service and the complete absence of the requisite notice itself. The practical consequence of this judgment is that any current or future reassessment proceedings initiated without strict adherence to the notice requirement of Section 143(2) will be viewed as legally non-existent, mandating that the tax department ensures all procedural checkboxes, particularly the issuance of notices, are verified before embarking on the task of reassessing established tax returns.