
The Securities Appellate Tribunal (SAT) has held that income tax paid on alleged unlawful gains cannot be deducted from disgorgement ordered by the Securities and Exchange Board of India. According to reports from The Hindu BusinessLine and Moneycontrol, the Tribunal rejected the plea on tax adjustment, stating that any relief relating to income tax paid on the disputed gains would have to be pursued separately under tax laws. SAT said it was appropriate for the applicants to seek remedy under the Income Tax Act, 1961. The Tribunal observed that proceedings under the Income Tax Act and actions initiated by SEBI operate in entirely different legal spheres and serve different objectives.
The application sought reconsideration of SAT's January 29, 2026 order in a case involving alleged fraudulent trades linked to stock recommendations aired on television by Pradeep Pandya. As reported by The Hindu BusinessLine and Moneycontrol, the investigation period covered November 2019 to October 2021, while SEBI's disgorgement order was passed in June 2024. The appellants challenged the earlier order on three grounds: computation of disgorgement, denial of adjustment for income tax paid on trading gains, and imposition of ₹25 lakh as costs. The case involves Alpesh Furiya and associated entities who were directed to disgorge ₹10.73 crore allegedly earned through transactions linked to stock recommendations and market-related violations.
Appellants argued that trades amounting to ₹3.16 crore had been executed before the stock recommendations were issued and therefore, should not have been included while calculating unlawful gains. According to the SAT order dated May 8, the Tribunal rejected this contention, stating that the applicants' argument that disgorgement must be calculated as the difference between quoted price at the time of recommendation and sale price was meritless. The entire gain was rightly construed by the WTM as wrongful gain and upheld by SAT in the order under review. However, SAT granted partial relief by upholding SEBI's disgorgement direction of ₹7.56 crore but remanded the issue relating to the disputed ₹3.16 crore back to SEBI for fresh computation.
Despite rejecting most of the plea, SAT granted partial relief by waiving the ₹25-lakh costs imposed in its earlier order. As reported by The Hindu BusinessLine and Moneycontrol, the Tribunal noted that the appellants had already deposited more than 90 per cent of the disgorgement amount at a preliminary stage. The ruling refers to the Monal Y Thakker vs ACIT case by the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (ITAT), Ahmedabad, where payments made to SEBI in disgorgement proceedings had been excluded for income tax purposes. SAT emphasized that any claim for adjustment, deduction, or exclusion arising from disgorgement payments would have to be pursued under the Income Tax Act before the appropriate tax authorities and could not be considered within SEBI proceedings.