
The Securities Appellate Tribunal (SAT) on Wednesday reserved its order in appeals filed by high-frequency trader Jane Street seeking additional information and details from the market regulator, the Securities and Exchange Board of India (Sebi), to prepare its response to the ex parte order issued on July 3, 2025. According to reports from Informist Media, both Sebi and Jane Street entities submitted their final written submissions before the appellate tribunal on Wednesday, following oral arguments that took place from October 5 to October 8. The tribunal had set Wednesday as the deadline for final submissions after the oral arguments concluded on October 8.
During the hearing, Jane Street had argued that it was seeking order logs from the market regulator with details of counterparties, timestamps, prices and quantities, which it noted were 'relevant' for its defence. As reported by Informist Media, Sebi had argued that it had already provided the information on which it had relied at this stage and that the counterparty information was redacted as it was irrelevant, given that there was no allegation of collusion with counterparties. The regulator added that the matter was at the investigative stage. The case involves four Jane Street group entities--JSI Investments Pvt. Ltd., JSI2 Investments Pvt. Ltd., Jane Street Singapore Pte. Ltd., and Jane Street Asia Trading Ltd.-- who filed a joint appeal in the Securities Appellate Tribunal against Sebi's refusal to provide all documents and data sought by them.
The case stems from Sebi's interim order in July 2025, in which the regulator accused US-based trading firm Jane Street and its group entities of manipulating the Bank Nifty index through a two-part trading strategy and alleged unlawful gains of about ₹4,843 crore. According to Informist Media, Sebi's investigation, which is still not complete, of specific periods and trades of the Jane Street group entities on the National Stock Exchange only had exposed suspected manipulation in the Nifty Bank and Nifty 50 indices on certain index option expiry days through manipulative trading patterns involving large positions in index options, index futures, and underlying index stocks in the cash market. The Jane Street group entities were ordered by SEBI to disgorge alleged unlawful gains of ₹48.44 billion, which they did, subject to the final outcome of the investigation. The current appeal represents Jane Street's efforts to obtain additional documentation to prepare its comprehensive defence against these allegations.
The Securities Appellate Tribunal is expected to issue its ruling in the case within a couple of months, as reported by Informist Media. Following the tribunal's final ruling, SEBI is expected to issue a confirmatory order in the case after the tribunal gives its final ruling and the Jane Street group entities formally respond to SEBI's charges in the interim order. This timeline suggests the case may be approaching its final resolution phase after nearly two years of legal proceedings.