
The Supreme Court on Monday issued notice on global consulting firm EY's plea challenging a Delhi high court ruling that treated payments made by its Indian entities to its US arm for employees deputed to India as fees for technical services rather than salary reimbursements. A bench of Justice J.B. Pardiwala and Justice K. Vinod Chandran agreed to examine whether salary reimbursements to Ernst & Young U.S. LLP can be taxed as fees for technical services when the deputed employees work under the control of Indian entities and tax has already been deducted from their salaries. The matter will next be heard on 1 December.
The case centers on employee secondment arrangements, under which employees are temporarily transferred from an overseas company to work for its Indian group entity. The key question is whether payments made by the Indian entity to its overseas counterpart merely reimburse employee costs or amount to payments for technical services that can be taxed in India. The dispute hinges on whether payments for overseas employee secondments are mere cost reimbursements or taxable fees for technical services. Consulting and technology firms, as well as companies operating global capability centres in India, will closely watch the case as the Supreme Court's eventual ruling could affect how multinational companies structure such arrangements, as well as their tax liabilities and withholding-tax obligations. The high court ruling had important implications for multinational companies' employee secondment arrangements, including greater tax scrutiny and potential impacts on withholding tax and goods and services tax (GST), according to a 6 July 2026 analysis by law firm Trilegal.
The dispute covers assessment years 2018-19 to 2022-23 and concerns employees deputed by Ernst & Young U.S. LLP (EY US) to its Indian entities. According to Mint reports, for assessment year 2019-20, the assessing officer passed an order on 27 July 2022, adding about ₹50.99 crore to EY US's taxable income. The tax department argued that the payments were not merely salary reimbursements but consideration for technical knowledge, skills and expertise provided to the Indian entities. Simply labelling payments as salary reimbursements may not suffice where overseas entities retain employment links, and employees transfer technical expertise to Indian entities. Similar disputes arose for other assessment years, with the tax department challenging the ITAT's orders before the Delhi high court.
EY US argued that the payments covered only employee-related costs and did not constitute income earned from providing technical services. In an order dated 20 June 2023, the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (ITAT) ruled in EY's favour on the secondment issue, holding that the payments were cost-to-cost reimbursements and did not qualify as fees for technical services under the India-US tax treaty. The tribunal subsequently decided similar disputes for other assessment years. However, the tax department challenged the ITAT's orders before the Delhi high court, which found that EY US retained significant links with the employees, who remain on its rolls while working in India. The court ruled in favour of the I-T department on the principal secondment issue, holding that the payments qualified as fees for technical services. The dispute resolution panel subsequently upheld the tax demand, while the Delhi High Court set aside the ITAT's orders in favour of EY US on the secondment issue.
The dispute covers assessment years 2018-19 to 2022-23 and concerns employees deputed by Ernst & Young U.S. LLP (EY US) to its Indian entities. Under an arrangement dating to October 2017, employees remained on EY US's rolls, retained certain employment benefits in the US, and were expected to return after completing their assignments. EY India reimbursed EY US for the costs associated with these employees. The court also examined the payments EY US received from Indian clients for services performed in the US. It found that the ITAT had not sufficiently examined the nature of these services and sent several related issues back to the tribunal for fresh consideration. EY filed its appeal before the Supreme Court on 15 September 2026. Separately, the Delhi High Court remanded issues concerning payments for professional services rendered from the US to Indian clients to the ITAT for fresh consideration in four of the appeals before it.