
India's $900-billion asset management industry is mounting a comprehensive push for capital gains tax reforms to stem the foreign investor exodus and make Indian markets more attractive. According to reports from Bloomberg, Edelweiss Financial Services Chairman Rashesh Shah stated that 'We need to showcase to the foreigners we want them' and emphasized that 'removing capital gains tax for foreigners might be an easier answer' for India to become a 'good permanent' allocation. The growing chorus comes as global funds are on track to pull money out of equities for an unprecedented third-straight year, with outflows nearing a record $27 billion this year alone. Asset managers argue that removing capital gains levies could help improve after-tax returns for foreigners, a key factor in their calculations for portfolio allocation, particularly given the rupee's sharp depreciation against the dollar in recent years.
Prashant Jain, founder of 3P Investment Managers, has defended India's current Long-Term Capital Gains (LTCG) tax structure as 'equitable', pushing back against calls for cuts to incentivize foreign investment. According to reports from CNBC-TV18, Jain highlighted that salaried middle-class individuals earning ₹20 lakh to ₹50 lakh annually pay 30% to 40% in income tax, whereas ultra-high-net-worth individuals earn the bulk of their income through capital gains. Speaking in a special interaction for the upcoming Samvat 2083 on Wednesday, November 4, Jain stated that 'taxation should be equitable' and emphasized that investors are primarily drawn to decent growth potential rather than tax incentives. 'I think the current rates I think are very fair. I don't think anyone would invest in a company or a stock market just because tax is not there,' Jain told CNBC-TV18.
Finance Minister Nirmala Sitharaman has said she will consider tax changes on stocks, but stopped short of confirming whether the government was looking at revisions to capital gains or transaction taxes. According to Bloomberg, long-term gains on listed equities held for more than a year are taxed at 12.5%, while short-term returns are levied 20%. The levy was introduced in 2018, and Sitharaman did flag that India attracted strong capital inflows in 2023 and 2024 when it was in place. However, Ananth Narayan, former whole-time member at India's markets regulator, told CNBC TV18 that the country has seen net outflows from foreign portfolio investors since 2019. A recent selloff in global artificial intelligence stocks and a decline in oil prices has offered a breather, with foreigners investing more than $3.5 billion last week through Thursday and helping drive the stock market's best week in more than five years.
The fund management industry is also seeking long-term gains on debt mutual funds taxed in line with equities, rather than at investors' applicable income-tax rates. As reported by Bloomberg, Srinivas Jain, joint CEO at SBI Funds Management Ltd., stated that 'investors need a compelling reason to allocate to debt' and noted that taxing gains at a higher rate 'weakens that incentive and makes it harder to build balanced portfolios'. The government and regulators should encourage more flows into fixed income and bond markets, according to Mihir Kapadia, chairman at Sun Global Investments, who noted there is 'a wall of capital available' if some restrictions on debt markets are removed or Indian corporates and state-run firms are encouraged to raise capital through dollar and masala bonds. Masala bonds, rupee-denominated debt securities sold abroad by issuers, could also attract more foreign investment if encouraged.
Indian equity markets are positioned to deliver a compound annual growth rate of 12% to 15% over the next three to five years, driven by economic growth and corporate profits rather than foreign capital, according to Jain. As reported by CNBC-TV18, he added that India has outgrown its dependence on overseas capital and noted that domestic inflows reach ₹40,000 crore to ₹50,000 crore every month. Shah estimates that Indian mutual funds could channel about $40 billion to $50 billion annually into equities, while insurance companies and pension funds could contribute another $20 billion to $25 billion, translating into new annual domestic equity inflows of roughly $60 billion to $80 billion. The veteran fund manager noted that markets are, in the long term, driven by the economy and the underlying businesses, not the other way around, with the economy growing between 7% and 8% and corporate profit growth being extremely strong.