
Market veteran Shankar Sharma, founder of GQuant Investech, has issued a stark warning about systematic investment plans (SIPs), calling them a threat to macroeconomic stability and expecting them to disappoint investors. In a recent conversation with Mint, Sharma argues that SIPs are draining foreign exchange on an even larger scale than gold, comparing them unfavorably to the restricted gold market. He believes the government should sacrifice the equity market to save the currency by reducing taxes on foreign investors and raising taxes on domestic mutual fund investors, stating that no stock market crash has ever ruined a nation, but currency and interest-rate crises have. Sharma has been warning about SIPs causing a potential macroeconomic disaster for two years, citing India's foreign-exchange reserves as a powder keg rather than a war chest.
According to research by Edelweiss Mutual Fund, even a 10-year systematic investment plan (SIP) could end with losses, particularly in small-cap stocks. The worst 10-year rolling SIP return for the Nifty Smallcap 250 Total Returns Index (TRI) was -0.13%, while the Nifty Midcap 150 TRI delivered a minimum annualised return of 6.37% and the Nifty 100 TRI generated at least 5.07%. The findings highlight significant differences in returns across market capitalisations, with small-caps recording the highest maximum return but experiencing the widest variation in outcomes. Sharma's analysis supports this view, noting that equity markets were never designed to enrich the masses and tend to strip wealth from the many while making a few fabulously rich.
Small-cap SIPs experienced the most extreme variations in returns over ten-year periods, according to the Edelweiss data. The Nifty Smallcap 250 TRI recorded a minimum annualised return of -0.13% and a maximum of 22.20%, with its average rolling return standing at 15.01%. In contrast, mid-caps delivered more consistent performance with the Nifty Midcap 150 TRI generating an average annualised SIP return of 17.61%, ranging between 6.37% and 23.60%. Large-cap index delivered an average return of 12.95%, with returns between 5.07% and 17.02%. Sharma's warning comes as he estimates that genuine bull markets have occupied only around 15% of the 41-year Sensex history, with the post-pandemic bull market delivering returns about 40% lower than the exceptional UPA-I period between 2004-2007.
The performance gap between market capitalisations becomes more pronounced over five-year periods, as reported by Edelweiss. The worst five-year rolling SIP return for the Nifty Smallcap 250 TRI was -16.81%, compared with -6.71% for the Nifty Midcap 150 TRI and -3.03% for the Nifty 100 TRI. Small-caps delivered a maximum annualised return of 38.26% over five years, higher than mid-caps at 36.14% and large-caps at 22.95%. However, mid-caps again led in average returns, generating 17.64% compared with 15.48% for small-caps and 13.01% for large-caps. Sharma's analysis supports this trend, noting that SIPs work well only in one market – the US, with the 'Mutual Funds Sahi Hai' campaign being one of the most misleading campaigns ever, as it fails to account for taxes and risk in the promised 12-15% compound annual returns.
Recent market conditions demonstrate the volatility impact on real SIP investments, as evidenced by a portfolio case showing XIRR declining from 19% to 13% over the last year. Despite this decline, the ₹60 lakh portfolio continues monthly SIPs of ₹30,000 and maintains a positive overall return. Financial experts emphasize that equity mutual funds can experience periods of weak returns even when long-term outlook remains reasonable, and that continuing SIPs based on cash flow and investment goals is more important than recent returns. The analysis reveals that SIPs spread investments across market levels but do not protect investors against market losses, requiring investors to distinguish between regular investment benefits and underlying asset class risks. Sharma's contrarian perspective suggests that households should prioritize fixed income, gold, and selective real estate investments rather than continuing SIPs in the current environment.