
An Argentine federal judge has dismissed the LIBRA criminal case against President Javier Milei and 11 other defendants, including his sister Karina and U.S. businessman Hayden Davis, after 19 months of investigation. According to reports from Reuters, Judge Marcelo Martínez de Giorgi issued the 60-page decision on October 23 after prosecutor Eduardo Taiano sought the dismissals, with none of the defendants having been called for formal questioning. The decision covers Mauricio Novelli, Manuel Terrones Godoy, Sergio Morales, Julian Peh, María Alicia Rafaele, María Pía Novelli, Camilo Rodríguez Blanco, Orlando Mellino, and KIP Protocol CEO Julian Peh alongside the Milei siblings and Davis. As reported by Reuters, Judge Martínez de Giorgi stated that 'The reported events do not constitute a criminal offense' and found that investigators could not establish the contents of Milei's launch-day calls with Mauricio Novelli. In his 60-page ruling, the judge wrote that 'a promotion, a rally, and a crash do not prove fraud alone' and added that 'an economic loss is not automatically a crime.'
The cryptocurrency's financial impact was devastating, with LIBRA losing more than 95% of its value after reaching about $5, according to blockchain researchers cited by Reuters. Wallets linked to the token's creator withdrew around $99 million in cryptocurrency, as reported by Chequeado. Davis claimed he held close to $100 million after the crash but denied wrongdoing. The investigation revealed that Milei had hailed the $LIBRA memecoin in a social media post in February 2025, stating 'The world wants to invest in Argentina. $LIBRA.' He deleted the post hours later after the currency crashed. According to AFP, Milei later denied promoting the virtual currency, saying he 'did not know the details of the project.' Within just seven hours of launch, LIBRA had plunged 96%, wiping out over $4 billion in market value, as reported by AMBCrypto. The token was trading at $0.00007433 at press time after a drop of 2.7% in the past 24 hours, according to AMBCrypto. On-chain analysts found that eight wallets tied to the team cashed out $107 million, as reported by CoinDesk.
The judge found that investigators could not establish the contents of Milei's launch-day calls with Mauricio Novelli, as reported by Infobae. The court accepted the prosecutor's reasoning that the token's promotion, price rally, and subsequent collapse were insufficient to establish fraud without evidence of a specific deception. Judge Martínez de Giorgi acknowledged that Milei's endorsement could have given the launch 'greater impact,' but ruled that his social media post and LIBRA's subsequent collapse were insufficient to establish fraud. On Karina Milei, investigators examined unsigned documents and notes recovered from Novelli's phone, but found insufficient evidence that she had received payment for arranging access to the president. According to Chequeado, the judge also found no evidence that Karina Milei sought or received money in exchange for access to the president, or that proceeds from LIBRA reached public officials. The judge rejected allegations of abuse of authority and conduct incompatible with public office, noting that Milei's post came from his personal X account and that investigators had not established official government involvement in the project. Investigators also could not link a note on Novelli's phone describing $5 million in payments to anyone else, as reported by CoinDesk.
Following the ruling, Milei slammed what he called a politically motivated case, posting on social media platform X: 'And now, who will compensate me for one year, eight months and nine days of lies, slander, and defamation aimed at tarnishing my good name and honor?' At a Fundación Faro event, Milei repeated his demand for compensation and alleged an attempt to remove him through institutional channels, as reported by Infobae. The event took place at the think tank led by Agustín Laje, with U.S. Ambassador Peter Lamelas and Argentina's ambassador to the United States, Alec Oxenford among those present. The Office of the President issued its own statement celebrating the ruling, citing Article 336, subsection 3, of Argentina's criminal procedure code, which provides for dismissal when the investigated events do not constitute a crime. However, opposition deputy Maximiliano Ferraro called the decision a judicial cover-up, with his congressional commission having found in November 2025 that Milei provided essential collaboration to the project, as reported by CoinDesk. Critics also questioned the July appointment of the judge's wife to a federal court, which Milei signed by decree. Ferraro's commission had previously found that the LIBRA project was 'a political and media operation against his government,' according to CoinDesk.
The case may not be fully closed, as reported by Reuters. Prosecutor Eduardo Taiano, who requested the dismissal, is not expected to appeal. In July, the judge removed the investors who had joined the case as plaintiffs, and an appeals court upheld that decision in September. Those investors have challenged their removal before the Federal Criminal Cassation Court. If they are reinstated, they could appeal the dismissal. The probe, opened ahead of Argentina's 2025 midterm elections, was characterized by the president's office as an attempt to harm Milei's reputation in an election year. The court has archived the case, but excluded plaintiffs have asked the Federal Cassation Court to reinstate them, which could reopen the door to an appeal, as reported by CoinDesk. For now, the court has archived the case, but the ruling has sparked debate about whether it represents a cover-up or proper judicial decision.