
A Mumbai court on Thursday denied anticipatory bail to businessman Sudhir Valia, an accused in an alleged ₹1,000-crore financial fraud linked to Yes Bank. Additional Sessions Judge Anil D Salunkhe rejected Valia's plea, stating that the charges against him are serious and his custodial interrogation is essential. The court found that the allegations against Valia and Yes Bank officials are serious on account of alleged fraud running into crores. As per the court order, "Considering the seriousness of the alleged economic fraud committed by the applicant, the custodial interrogation of the applicant is essential." The judge noted that "Prima facie, the contents in the FIR and remaining investigation papers show allegations against the present applicant as well as officers of YES Bank are serious." The judge also noted that "According to me, prima facie record does not show involvement of the applicant in the case as false or to malign his reputation," while refusing pre-arrest protection to Valia.
The Mumbai Police's Economic Offences Wing (EOW) has registered a fresh FIR against Yes Bank co-founder Rana Kapoor, Valia, director of Suraksha Asset Reconstruction Ltd (Suraksha ARC), and others for alleged illegal transfer of mortgaged property worth ₹1,000 crore. The case was registered at the Worli police station on a complaint filed by Lakhminder Dayal Singh, associated with Saffair Land Development, a sister concern of Housing Development and Infrastructure Ltd (HDIL). The FIR alleges that Privilege Power and Infrastructure, another HDIL group company, had taken a loan of ₹300 crore from the Worli branch of Yes Bank in 2015, while Saffair Land Development sought a loan of ₹150 crore sanctioned by the private bank in 2016. According to the court order, "As per the FIR, they, in collusion with each other, created forged record to grab the property of more than Rs 1,000 crore mortgaged by the informants company in favour of Yes Bank against Rs 150 crore loan obtained from the private lender for a period of three years."
According to the FIR, properties valued at ₹1,000 crore of HDIL and its group companies were mortgaged with the bank for securing the loan, which was to be repaid within 36 months. However, Singh alleged that in June 2018, Yes Bank had authorised Suraksha ARC to recover ₹176.53 crore from his company even though the repayment period was yet to get over. Singh claimed that the mortgaged property valued at ₹1,000 crore was illegally transferred to Suraksha ARC even though the company had not been declared a Non-Performing Asset (NPA), as noted in a 2019 special audit report. The complainant alleged that the properties were sold off at below-the-market rate. The FIR further alleged that Yes Bank arranged ₹22.5 crore as margin money for Suraksha ARC, which was routed through multiple accounts as part of a conspiracy to take control of the mortgaged properties. Public Prosecutor Ashwini Rayakar argued that "This applicant and director of his company acted with collusion of the officer of YES Bank. They created forged documents and YES Bank provided funds to the tune of Rs 22.5 crore to Valia's company to grab assets worth more than Rs 1,000 crore, mortgaged by the complainant's company in favour of YES Bank, and thereafter succeeded in grabbing the same by creating forged documents."
In his pre-arrest bail plea, Valia denied all allegations against him, stating he has been falsely implicated in the case with malicious intent. Valia's plea described the entire case as an attempt by a suspended director to weaponize the criminal justice system over a concluded, fully documented financial transaction. The defence argued that Valia is merely one of the six directors at Suraksha ARC, a public limited company, and the FIR fails to attribute any specific meeting, email, instruction, or overt act to him personally. "The FIR fails to attribute any specific meeting, email, instruction, or overt act to him personally, nor does it allege that he received any wrongful personal gain," Valia argued that the complaint did not show direct actions by Valia or personal benefit from the alleged deal. Senior counsel Pranav Badeka, Rishi Bhutta and Sagar Shetty, who appeared on behalf of the complainant, opposed the plea, stating that the accused acted covertly without giving notice to the company and that key paperwork is held by bank officials and Valia.
The prosecution clarified that the fraud only came to light after the informant reviewed an audit report of Yes Bank as the accused had acted covertly without giving a notice to the company. Rayakar told the court that the accused acted covertly and did not give notice to the company, and that key paperwork is held by bank officials and Valia. The EOW argued that a complete probe cannot proceed without Valia's custodial interrogation, as "a thorough investigation is impossible without custodial interrogation of Valia." The court's order left Valia without pre-arrest protection as the investigation continues, with the EOW examining the loan, recovery steps, and the alleged role of Yes Bank officers, Suraksha ARC, and other accused in the disputed property transfer involving mortgaged assets and internal records.